TeamOrigin even the scales

As Synergy lose out in a collision with Emirates Team New Zealand at the Louis Vuitton Trophy

Emirates Team New Zealand may have been the strongest team at the Louis Vuitton Trophy Nice Côte d’Azur, but Synergy Russia Sailing Team has been the most surprising. Those forces collided today in the Semi Final Round of the regatta, and tonight the two teams are in the protest room trying to resolve an incident at the finish of their second race.

Team New Zealand won a thrilling first race by 20 seconds. The heat featured three lead changes and the Kiwis won after gaining control in a luffing match with the finish line about 10 lengths away.

“It was all on, a very close race,” said Team New Zealand tactician Ray Davies. “It was pretty tense onboard. You have to expect close races in this round. We’re down to the best teams and you have to expect close, ding-dong races otherwise they wouldn’t be worth winning.”

In the second race Team New Zealand was penalised in the pre-start for gybing too close. The Kiwis controlled the race around the track, but couldn’t get enough separation to perform the 270-degree penalty turn and convert the win.

A collision occurred when the pair was outside the committee boat end of the finish line. According to Synergy skipper Karol Jablonski, Team New Zealand called for water to clear the boat end. Jablonski said he responded to the call, but the yachts were downspeed and he had little steerage. The two 24-tonne yachts collided beam-on-beam and suffered some damage.

Although Synergy won the match on the water to even the score at 1-1, the protest was still hanging in the balance. A ruling was expected later tonight.

This regatta has suffered through starts and stops the past two weeks due to light winds. But that was all in distant memory today as the conditions on the Baie des Anges kicked up and added a compelling measure to the racing. Five penalties were issued and two teams were OCS as the conditions put a premium on boathandling.

After the morning offshore flow died, the wind shifted to the east and built to 15 knots, with gusts up to 18 knots - the freshest breeze of the regatta to date. There was also a large seaway running as the winds offshore were blowing up to 25 knots.

TeamOrigin evened the scoreline with Italy's Azzurra at 1-1. The British team had the favoured right hand entry, a strong and confident boat handling crew and Team Principal Sir Keith Mills on board as 18th man.

Right from the entry it was clear Ainslie was in control, choosing not to dial-up beside the Italian at the last moment, and then managing to tack quickly around and start to hustle the opponent out to the extremities of the right hand side of the start box. The Italian’s found a large spectator boat 400 metres along the startline extension to sail around and try and offload the chasing British team. The British afterguard, anticipating the move, sailed the other side of the same boat and caught the Italian in a compromised position trying to manoeuvre, called foul and were awarded a penalty. 1-0 to Ainslie.

It wasn’t over. There were still two minutes to run to the start and Ainslie continued to harry the Italian back to the line at speed, still most definitely in control. In the last 30 seconds to the start with both on port tack heading for the committee boat it became clear that the Italian was going to be early and had no where to go. He could bail out to leeward of the committee boat or start prematurely. 2-0 to Ainslie. He chose the latter and managed to foul TeamOeigin a second time as well as needing to return around the committee boat to start correctly. 3-0 to Ainslie, and the British boat disappeared up the course to sail effectively unopposed and win by a margin of two miles 29 seconds.

Sir Keith Mills, Team Principal, commented after the race “We had an awesome start today, Ben and the team gave Azzurra two penalties and pushed them over the line at the start. The guys sailed a perfect race – all to play for tomorrow though!”

Ben Ainslie, Skipper and Helmsman, added “It was great to finally race in some wind and waves. It was a ‘must win’ race for us, the guys did a great job all the way around. We have a long way to go yet in this competition being first on tomorrow.”

“For sure today was harder for the crew, for everybody,” said Bruni. “To go from 15 days of very, very light wind and flat water to these conditions, to switch is hardest for me. I wasn’t as ready as Ben. I think he did a good job.”

In Knockout Round racing, the combined French/German team All4One placed fifth after winning two races. All4One earned a well-deserved win against Artemis by 27 seconds in its first race, and then met BMW Oracle Racing for 5th and 6th places. BMW Oracle had defeated TFS-PagesJaunes in its first race.

BMW Oracle controlled the match early, but made an unforced error at the windward mark. Approaching the first mark on starboard with All4One on its stern, BMW Oracle helmsman Gavin Brady tacked to port to round the mark. But All4One had to bear away to avoid hitting BMW Oracle, and the on-water umpires issued a red flag penalty.

BMW Oracle had to perform its penalty immediately on the run, and when it did so All4One sailed into a commanding lead. All4One won the match by 1 minute, 23 seconds to place 5th and drop BMW Oracle to 6th.

“This morning we had nothing to lose,” said All4One helmsman Sebastien Col. “We had the best conditions we could dream of for Nice. We were really waiting for these conditions because I think we have a strong team that can handle the boat well in a breeze. We started the regatta slowly and had some tough moments, but we are happy to finish well. It’s good for the team.”

Artemis of Sweden placed 7th on countback, and TFS-PagesJaunes finished 8th.
Racing is scheduled to resume tomorrow morning with a warning signal set for 0830 CET. The first race will be between TeamOrigin and Azzurra.

Semi Final standings
M1: Emirates Team New Zealand 1, Synergy Russia Sailing Team 1 (protest pending)
M2: Azzurra 1, TeamOrigin 1

Knockout Round standings
5th: All4One
6th: BMW Oracle Racing
7th: Artemis
8th: TFS – PagesJaunes

Following this...

The International Jury for the Louis Vuitton Trophy Nice Côte d’Azur has penalised Synergy Russia Sailing Team a half point for a collision with Emirates Team New Zealand at the finish of their second Semi Final race earlier today.

In the second race Emirates Team New Zealand had been penalised in the pre-start for gybing too close. The crew carried that penalty around the course. Approaching the finish, Team New Zealand was trying to either complete the 270-degree penalty turn or offset it with a penalty on Synergy when the pair wound up outside the committee boat end of the finish line.

Both crews had their genoas hoisted trying to get upwind and over the top of the committee boat, but Team New Zealand got close to the committee boat. The New Zealand crew tacked to port and hailed for water, calling the committee boat an obstruction.

Both boats were downspeed in the sloppy seaway and they collided, Synergy’s port side hitting Team New Zealand’s starboard side.

After the match the on-water umpires penalised Emirates Team New Zealand 1 point and Synergy a half point for the beam-on-beam collision that caused some damage to the 24-tonne yachts.

In a later protest hearing the International jury found that there was a hard collision between Team New Zealand and Synergy. The jury deemed that when Synergy, the starboard-tack yacht, became the right-of-way boat it altered course down towards Team New Zealand and didn’t do enough to keep clear.

“That change of course was an infringement of Rule 14 (Avoiding Contact), so we deducted a half point for that,” said Chief Umpire Bill Edgerton. “In the end we penalised Team new Zealand 1 point and Synergy a half point for the rule to make sure the crews don’t do massive damage. Then we deducted a second half point from Synergy for not doing everything to keep clear.”

Although the teams have each won a race in their match the score is now 0-0, setting up a one race, winner-take-all match tomorrow morning.

Racing is scheduled to resume tomorrow morning with a warning signal set for 0830 CET. The first race will be between TeamOrigin and Azzurra with the Emirates Team New Zealand-Synergy to follow.

Semi Final standings
M1: Emirates Team New Zealand 0, Synergy Russia Sailing Team 0
M2: Azzurra 1, TeamOrigin 1